The Battle for Congress: Data and Strategy for the 2026 US Midterms

This policy paper provides a data-driven forecast of the 2026 U.S. midterm elections, arguing that structural and political conditions overwhelmingly favor a Democratic takeover of the House of Representatives. Data journalist and election forecaster G. Elliott Morris analyzes the rapid fracturing of President Donald Trump’s 2024 winning coalition. Driven by deep voter dissatisfaction over the affordability crisis and tariff-induced inflation, key demographic groups—specifically Latinos, independents, and young voters—have swung sharply back toward the Democratic Party.

Supported by precinct-level data from the 2025 off-year elections and historical regression models, the paper demonstrates that Trump’s ~40% approval rating aligns with historical patterns that virtually guarantee significant midterm losses for the incumbent party. The analysis also explores the impact of mid-decade redistricting battles, concluding that while Republican gerrymandering efforts may blunt the magnitude of a "blue wave," they cannot overcome the structural headwinds. Finally, the paper assesses the Senate map, concluding that while a Democratic House flip is highly probable, regaining the Senate remains a steep structural challenge for the party.

This policy paper offers a strategic and qualitative assessment of the 2026 U.S. midterm elections, emphasizing the unprecedented volatility shaping the current political landscape. Republican strategist Kodiak Hill-Davis agrees with structural forecasts that Democrats are likely to reclaim the House of Representatives, but argues that traditional models may underestimate the chaos of the current cycle. The paper explores the paradox of an electorate forced to choose between two historically unpopular parties, both of which are currently engulfed in internal conflicts.

For the GOP, the rapid decline of President Trump’s approval, driven by severe economic backlash against his tariff policies and deadly immigration enforcement, threatens to alienate the very coalition of Latinos, young men, and non-college voters that delivered his 2024 victory. Meanwhile, the Democratic Party is paralyzed by an ideological struggle between progressives pushing for base mobilization and moderates advocating for centrist appeals. Furthermore, Hill-Davis highlights how external political shocks, such as the recent Supreme Court ruling, can inadvertently shift economic pressures like inflation and rescue Republican electoral prospects, proving that the 2026 midterms will be defined as much by political unpredictability as by historical precedent.

Download Elliot's Paper

G. Elliot Morris Outlook on 2026 Midterms

Download Kodiak's Paper

Kodiak Hill-Davis Analysis Key Factors 2026 Midterms